Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in Please refresh your browser to be logged in
Open full menu
US Edition
It remains early days, but there are few signs of progress in Pocognoli’s new approach and the regression Scotland have made in the past 12 months has been alarming. By Jamie Braidwood

Monday 16 November 2026 23:04 GMT
Copy link

open image in gallery
Andy Robertson’s historic night ended in a damaging defeat to Switzerland(PA)

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
DeeperDive is a GenAI Answer Engine built for trusted publishers. It delivers clear answers and real-time content based on what people are reading now — showcasing various stories from the The Independent Network that highlight not just what happened, but why it matters.
Ask The Independent AI anything
What results has Pocognoli achieved in six games?
How does Nations League result affect Euro 2028 draw?
Ask The Independent
DeeperDive AI
DeeperDive is a GenAI Answer Engine built for trusted publishers. It delivers clear answers and real-time content based on what people are reading now — showcasing various stories from the The Independent Network that highlight not just what happened, but why it matters.
Full Summary
Scotland suffered a 4-0 defeat to a second-string Switzerland side, raising questions about Sebastien Pocognoli's tenure after the team secured only two wins in six games. The loss concludes a Nations League campaign that saw the team regress since their World Cup qualification a year ago.
O n Wednesday, 18 November, it will be a year to the day since one of the greatest nights in Scotland’s history: the 4-2 win over Denmark that sensationally sealed qualification to the following summer’s World Cup. The BBC will be celebrating by showing a full match replay on Tuesday and many Scotland supporters who tuned into see a wretched end to their Nations League campaign on Monday evening will have wished they had just waited to watch that instead.
How dramatically Scotland’s fortunes have fallen in the 12 months since, as a miserable 4-0 defeat to a second-string Switzerland side with nothing to play for raised serious questions about the new era under Sebastien Pocognoli. It remains early days – there have only been six games since the departure of Steve Clarke –but Pocognoli has overseen just two wins, both of which came against North Macedonia. There has been little progress under the Belgian, and the complete absence of a statement result.
On what was a historic night for Andy Robertson, the record-breaking captain offered a damning assessment of their work so far in implementing Pocognoli’s new approach. “I don't think you've got time in international football,” he said. “Are they supporters that have travelled everywhere going to give us time? No. The people inside Hampden, are they going to give us time? No. Are the people outside Hampden that are going to be critical, and rightly so, are they going to give us time? No.”

open image in gallery
Sebastien Pocognoli has overseen just two wins over North Macedonia in his six games in charge(PA)
There were some bright signs in the first half in St Gallen, but then Scotland were the side with something on the line as they chased a victory that could have given them an outside chance of reaching a Nations League promotion play-off. Switzerland, by contrast, were already through as group winners. The World Cup quarter-finalists were missing many of their first-choice team and a much-changed, inexperienced side remained cohesive and took a first-half lead through Lewis Ferguson’s own goal.
Turning into his own net was a horrible moment for Ferguson, but it should not have been a disaster for Scotland. They had time at the break to turn it around. But what was perhaps the most alarming aspect of their surrender to the Swiss was how sloppy they were at the start of the second half, and the way their heads dropped after conceding twice in five minutes following the restart. It did not reflect well on Pocognoli that his players looked as if their confidence was on the floor.

Andy Robertson defied the odds to become Scotland’s greatest captain
It was notable, also, that Pocognoli appeared to snap at a reporter in response to a gentle pre-match questioning of his tactics and 3-4-3 formation. He wants his team to be front-footed and take the game to their opponents by pushing high up the pitch, but it’s clear for all to see that Scotland are struggling to combine that with being creative from open play and retaining defensive solidity. The mistakes in possession and at the back, once they went behind, suggested a lack of belief in the system they are trying to play. Scott McTominay has been anonymous playing as one of two No 10s, next to John McGinn, in his two appearances under Pocognoli.
Scotland had these issues too under Clarke, increasingly towards the end of his tenure and especially at the World Cup, but in qualifying or in the Nations League there was always the sense that the could rise to a challenge when they were being doubted. Scotland may have missed out on the Nations League play-offs even if they had won at Switzerland –as it happens, Slovenia won 3-0 at North Macedonia anyway –but beating even an inexperienced Switzerland side would have been a boost. Collapsing in the manner they did could be even more damaging.
As if to stress Robertson’s point, the Euro 2028 qualifying draw takes place at the start of the December, ahead of potentially staging the tournament on home soil 18 months later. Finishing the Nations League in third place in League B means Scotland will be stuck in Pot 3 of the draw. A potential four-team group could see them land next to Spain and Sweden and with just two automatic qualifying spots available. And while there are two qualification spaces left in reserve, should any of the co-hosts fail to qualify automatically, there are only two, and they will go to the teams with the best qualifying record: Scotland could be left praying for England, Wales and the Republic of Ireland to coast through.
Should they land in a five-team qualifying group, Scotland could be playing their Euro 2028 qualifiers by as early as the next international break in March. The Nations League carried ramifications but the series of six games across September, October and November where the time for Pocognoli to settle in. Now, there are just more questions than answers, and the clock towards the home Euros ticking while a sense of apathy among the Tartan Army grows.
In that context, Robertson’s message felt even more pertinent. “So we've not got time,” he said. “The players don't have time. We have to step up. Now we've got a long break until March, which is not a good thing. We really need to step up again because in international football, you don't have time.”
Scotland footballAndy RobertsonSteve ClarkeJohn McGinnScott McTominay
Promoted stories
South Carolina: Say Goodbye To High Car Insurance If You Live In These ZIPs Auto insurance rates can differ widely depending on your zip code. A quick check can show you which companies are offering attractive rates in your area right now. Spend a minute comparing options and see what’s available near you.US Auto Insurance | SponsoredSponsored Learn More
Undo
Here’s Why the Expert Says Micro Infusion Beats Everything Else Derma Reviews | SponsoredSponsored Learn More
Undo
Dentures or Implants? Most People Are Never Told of Option 3 Oralux | SponsoredSponsored Read More
Undo
Want to know more? click here- | SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Your South Carolina Zip Code Could Qualify You for Lower Auto Insurance Rates Auto insurance rates can differ widely depending on your zip code. A quick check can show you which companies are offering attractive rates in your area right now. Spend a minute comparing options and see what’s available near you.US Auto Insurance | SponsoredSponsored Learn More
Undo
Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging In South Carolina (Is Yours On The List?)Drivers Had No Idea They Could Do This Comparisons.org | SponsoredSponsored Learn More")
Undo
Brought to you by- | SponsoredSponsored
Undo
North Charleston: 24 Hour Dental Implants Take our 1-minute quiz to find out if you're eligible for our revolutionary 24-hour dental implants. Get a new smile in just 24 Hrs Nuvia Dental Implant Center | SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Expert: Do This Simple Routine Before You Start Botox Derma Reviews | SponsoredSponsored Learn More
Undo
Pay Off Credit Card Debt Without a Loan There's a program designed for people who owe at least $20,000.Weekly Financial Solutions | SponsoredSponsored Learn More
Undo
voices Russell Brand’s message from behind bars is as grim as it is unfathomable
Undo
news Third American aircraft carrier arrives in the Middle East as Trump keeps options open in Iran war
Undo
This may be of interest to you!- | SponsoredSponsored
Undo
news Paraguay’s ousted president moved to military prison after reports of gym and suite in custody
Undo
Simon Calder’s five off-the-radar European cities to visit this spring A quintet of locations that are enduring undertourism despite their many attractions Promoted by Independent Premium | SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Lab Grown Rings On Sale Online - Take a Look!Explore Lab Grown Rings On Sale Online With Responsible Style.AdvisorHQ.net | Lab Grown Rings | SponsoredSponsored Learn More
Undo
Additional resources on this topic- | SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Most People Refrigerate Bread. Bakers Do This Instead It's a simple cloth swap that keeps crust crisp for days.EverLoaf | SponsoredSponsored Shop Now
Undo
home news Russell Brand’s message from behind bars was ‘disgusting’ – Ed Miliband
Undo
east asia South Korea’s top scorer in tax accountancy exam admits to cheating using AI
Undo
Trucks For Seniors At Low Prices (Take A Look)Explore Affordable Trucks With Comfort In Mind AdvisorHQ.net | Trucks | SponsoredSponsored Learn More")
Undo
Explore related insights- | SponsoredSponsored
Undo
home news Russell Brand could have calls restricted after sharing ‘unacceptable’ prison message
Undo

The Simpsons predicted a blackout – and how the UK could react
lashes out over questions about DC projects after FAA crisis

Brand’s ‘appalling’ prison message being urgently investigated
do tech wives and divorcees do with their money?

is a Black Sky event? The disaster threat the UK is preparing for

I’m A Celeb star breaks down in tears after shock exit

Rooney conquers ‘biggest fear’ for I’m A Celebrity debut

eliminated Strictly star breaks silence on exit

a Celebrity 2026: The 5 highest-paid stars revealed

a Celebrity 2026: First contestant eliminated before reaching camp

does I’m a Celebrity 2026 start? Time, channel and full line-up

much is Wayne Rooney being paid for I'm a Celebrity?
Donald Trump’s hair is causing Republican party infighting
Promoted Links
Wrinkled Skin? Most People Use Moisturizer. Koreans Do This Instead Beauty Guide Read More
Undo
Residents In South Carolina With Credit Card Debt Could Be In For A Big Surprise Weekly Financial Solutions Learn More
Undo
South Carolina: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On The List?)Comparisons.org Learn More")
Undo
Costco Shoppers Swear By This 3rd Option Instead of Dentures and Implants Oralux
Undo
2026 Forester Pricing for Retirees Is Turning Heads - Take a Look!ProSearches | Forester Learn More
Undo
Timeshare Resorts Forced To Refund Owners - Is Yours On the List?SilverPenny Learn More
Undo
Ad: Unlock premier banking benefits with NatWest and get a £500 welcome bonus
Ad: Booking a last-minute holiday? Here’s why Cyprus should be on your radar
Ad: MyHeritage DNA tests reduced to lowest price for limited time
Ad: Skin feeling drier as the weather changes? Here’s how to adjust your skincare routine
Ad: Nourish your day with Protein Works Complete Meal 360
The Simpsons predicted a blackout – and how the UK could react
lashes out over questions about DC projects after FAA crisis
Brand’s ‘appalling’ prison message being urgently investigated
do tech wives and divorcees do with their money?
is a Black Sky event? The disaster threat the UK is preparing for
Close modal
Independent

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in Please refresh your browser to be logged in
Open full menu
US Edition
Keep on reading
Explore News for You
voices Russell Brand’s message from behind bars is as grim as it is unfathomable
Undo
US Auto Insurance South Carolina: Say Goodbye To High Car Insurance If You Live In These ZIPs
Undo
americas Cornell University launches major Greek system review after gang rape report
Undo
Derma Reviews Here’s Why the Expert Says Micro Infusion Beats Everything Else
Undo
uk politics Miliband condemns rapist Russell Brand’s ‘disgusting’ message from behind bars
Undo
Oralux Dentures or Implants? Most People Are Never Told of Option 3
Undo
news Prue Leith makes sad friendship admission: ‘It’s one of life’s few regrets’
Undo
us politics Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East as Trump keeps Iran war options open
Undo
us politics Trump’s hair at center of GOP leadership civil war as questions swirl over upkeep costs
Undo
Click here for more information- | SponsoredSponsored
Undo
US Auto Insurance Your South Carolina Zip Code Could Qualify You for Lower Auto Insurance Rates
Undo
Comparisons.org Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging In South Carolina (Is Yours On The List?)")
Undo
Nuvia Dental Implant Center North Charleston: 24 Hour Dental Implants
Undo
Derma Reviews Expert: Do This Simple Routine Before You Start Botox
Undo
Weekly Financial Solutions Pay Off Credit Card Debt Without a Loan
Undo
Beauty Guide Wrinkled Skin? Most People Use Moisturizer. Koreans Do This Instead
Undo
DeeperDive is a GenAI Answer Engine built for trusted publishers. It delivers clear answers and real-time content based on what people are reading now — showcasing various stories from the The Independent Network that highlight not just what happened, but why it matters.