The actor, writer, and director Jesse Eisenberg is what some might call a real character—hyperverbal, relentlessly self-deprecating, and visibly anxious, often to the point where his whole body shakes, like a dachshund in a thunderstorm. He writes and directs comedic films—three so far—that could be described as character studies: quirky, neurotic stories about quirky, neurotic people, whose lives, at least to the outside world, are more or less unremarkable. Whatever drama his characters encounter is almost entirely self-created, the result of some sort of private, metaphysical crisis breaking out in full, humiliating view of others.
Eisenberg’s third film, “The Debut,” which comes out next month, follows Mona Friedman, a meek, middle-aged housewife, played by Julianne Moore, living in a small town in nineteen-nineties New Jersey. Mona, who uses stilted phrases such as “a real hoot” and “rinky-dink,” feels invisible in her own life. On a whim, she auditions for a local production of a musical called “Nosy Neighbors,” about the tenants of a ratty New York apartment building. She lands the role of Miss Danielle, the building’s superintendent, who has just one song and a handful of lines. At first, Mona is truly terrible. But—under the tutelage of the show’s director, Jerry (Paul Giamatti)—she finds her footing, and before long, intoxicated by the spotlight, she becomes a nightmarishly egotistical diva. Eisenberg’s initial pitch to studios was “What would happen if a woman gets a part in a dumb musical and treats it like ‘Raging Bull’?”
Moore is considered a front-runner for the Best Actress Oscar for her alluringly odd performance. In one early scene, Mona, still in her wallflower phase, is standing in a supermarket checkout line, and a man asks to go ahead of her because, he says, “I got a ton of stuff.” Mona steps aside. The man is comically arrogant. (Who asks to go first when they have more items?) Mona is comically passive. (Who would let him?) But the dance between ego and self-effacement is one of Eisenberg’s central preoccupations.
Get our Classics newsletter to discover timeless gems from The New Yorker archive.
Eisenberg is forty-three. He began starring in films as a teen-ager and has been in dozens of movies since. At twenty-seven, he was nominated for an Oscar for Best Actor, for playing Mark Zuckerberg in David Fincher’s “The Social Network.” He wears more or less the same thing every day: scuffed sneakers, a rumpled T-shirt, and a fraying red baseball cap bearing the logo of Indiana University. (His wife, Anna Strout, is from Bloomington.) He owns, in total, “four pairs of pants,” he says. He and Strout, who works as a nonprofit organizer and an educator in the New York City public-school system, live, with their ten-year-old child, Banner, in a modest two-bedroom apartment near Washington Square Park. “The thing you have to understand about Jesse is that he is extremely famous, and he is not a normal person in the world—just try walking through Times Square with him—but he desperately, desperately insists that he is,” the writer Taffy Brodesser-Akner, who worked with him in 2022 on the television adaptation of her novel “Fleishman Is in Trouble,” said. Claire Danes, who starred opposite Eisenberg in “Fleishman,” told me about running into him on the street recently. “We stopped to chat, and so many people were rubbernecking,” she said. “People are very aware of him as a figure, even though he is so determined to be invisible.”
One way that Eisenberg tries to undermine his celebrity is by paying attention, to a nearly farcical degree, to other people. He can’t stand small talk—he prefers more in-depth interactions. “How long did it take him to ask you about your parents and your grandparents and your great-grandparents?” his younger sister, Hallie, a former child actor who is now a therapist, asked me. (Answer: About seven minutes.) Kieran Culkin, who won an Oscar for his starring role in “A Real Pain,” Eisenberg’s second film as a writer and director, noticed the same habit. “If he’s nervous in a situation, what he’ll do is, he’ll just talk to that person and intensely quiz them about their entire life,” Culkin told me. “I personally don’t give a shit about where people come from, or what their parents did for a living. I think he was fully baffled by that.” The actress Lizzy Caplan, his friend, put it this way: “He is sincerely interested in the health update on his makeup artist’s third cousin’s cat.”
Eisenberg’s inquisitiveness might seem surprising, given his skittish carriage and the fact that he often calls himself “a loner and a recluse.” And yet he appears to find relief in discussing his struggles—he has been in and out of therapy since he was a kid, for obsessive-compulsive disorder and generalized anxiety—and listening to those of others. The first time we met, for lunch at an Italian restaurant, he popped a Prozac shortly after sitting down and said that he had recently upped his dosage because editing “The Debut,” his psychiatrist thought, gave him enough of a lull to “experiment.”
The seesaw between ambition and self-abnegation is also evident in his work as a director. Eisenberg strives to make his sets feel like a “nonhierarchical” environment, he told me, where “no one person is more important than anybody else.” This was especially true of “The Debut.” “How could you be making a movie about a woman who’s an underdog, who no one notices, and then have a set where the people walking around feel like that?” he asked. “You’d have to be so stupid and blind and compartmentalizing, in a psychopathic way, to write a movie about that and then perpetuate it.”
One afternoon last winter, I dropped by the Brook Arts Center, in Bound Brook, New Jersey, an old vaudeville venue where Eisenberg was filming three scenes for “The Debut.” He’d been in the building since early that morning. He makes an effort, he told me, to be as present on set as possible and eats all his meals with the cast and crew. He has been known to fetch coffee for his performers.
Now Eisenberg sat in a director’s chair behind a video monitor, about twenty feet from the stage. The room was freezing cold—“We’re only here for two days,” Ali Herting, a producer on the film, said, “so I guess we didn’t pay for heat?”—and Eisenberg had one of his legs bent against his chest, for warmth. He was wearing a fake mustache. “I’m in a scene later,” he explained. At first, he had resisted being in the movie. He hates watching himself on camera—“I only see how weird my jaw looks, or what I’d do differently,” he told me—and said that editing “A Real Pain,” in which he co-starred, was “excruciating.” But Herting persuaded him to take a small role in the movie’s musical (for which Eisenberg wrote all the music and lyrics), as Barnaby, a tenant who has clogged his toilet.
Moore appeared stage right, wearing a green barn jacket over her costume (red coveralls, heavy tool belt), to do a brief scene with her castmate Halle Bailey. Bailey’s character, Stef, stars as Girl in 4F in “Nosy Neighbors.” Early on in the film, Stef gives Mona a trite pep talk that becomes a parody of itself. “Jerry is going to test you and push you and drag you through the shit and the mud, and you have to be ready to take those tests and wade through that shit and that mud, because when you finally get to opening night, Mona,” she says, “you’re going to knock those fuckers on their asses!”

Cartoon by Joe Dator
Bailey began a scene in which, after Mona wavers on saying a mundane line—it doesn’t feel realistic to her, she insists—Stef encourages her in the wings. “She’s amazing,” Eisenberg whispered, about Bailey. “But it feels a little... wishy-washy?” He had the actors run it again and then nodded. “It usually doesn’t get any better than the magic of the first one or two takes,” he said.
He likes his cast to stick to his script. “Jesse is the keeper of the tone,” Herting said. “He knows how to calibrate it so precisely, even when on the page it looks wild.” Despite Eisenberg’s sometimes jittery energy, he inspires a sense of trust in his actors. “You could easily mistake Jesse for this über-nebbish, who walks around deeply rattled, constantly, by the world,” Giamatti told me. “But,” he continued, “he knows exactly what he wants to do. He’s really thought about it.”
This fall, Eisenberg was notably absent from Aaron Sorkin’s “The Social Reckoning,” the sequel to Fincher’s 2010 film about the Facebook founder, for which Sorkin had written the screenplay. Sorkin wrote the new script with Eisenberg in mind, but Eisenberg turned down a series of escalating offers from Sony Pictures. (The role ultimately went to Jeremy Strong.) Sorkin and Eisenberg haven’t spoken much since making “The Social Network.” “I hardly know him at all,” Sorkin told me. And yet, he went on, “there’s something about Jesse that reminds me of Holden Caulfield, if that makes any sense. He has absolutely no patience for phonies.”
Eisenberg simply wasn’t interested in playing Zuckerberg again. “I can’t stand being associated with that person,” he told me. “I’m not on social media of any kind because it terrifies me.” For years, strangers passing Eisenberg on the street would yell “Hey, Zuck!” or “I’m C.E.O., bitch!” (a line from the film). The connection grated on him. “I’d be out at a bar and a drunk guy would say, ‘Hey, I love your website,’” he told me. “And as I’m pretending to laugh, I’d just wish all of the oxygen would leave my lungs, and that I would collapse on the floor in front of this guy and show him what he’s doing to me.”
By his own admission, Eisenberg is overly sensitive, but this can lend his performances a compelling fragility. In “The Social Network,” he managed to dramatize the act of thinking with very little physical movement; his Zuckerberg doesn’t rage but pulses—with intelligence, vengeance, and loneliness. Fincher encouraged him to lean into that lack of affect. “We’d do half of the takes where I was more animated, and then half where I would just empty myself out,” Eisenberg said. The result was mesmerizing. His Zuckerberg is simultaneously arrogant and needy, a villain who somehow solicits almost as much pity as contempt.
Eisenberg acknowledges that “The Social Network” had a positive effect on his career, if for no other reason than that it showed Hollywood he could be a bad guy. “After that, I got to play eccentrics and ecoterrorists,” he said. “Up until then, I was only cast as shy, sweet, nervous protagonists.” That typecasting began, in 2002, with “Roger Dodger,” in which Eisenberg played Nick, a naïve Midwestern teen who visits his uncle in Manhattan. Stephen Holden, of the Times, wrote that he struck “a lovely balance between crude adolescent avidity and an inner sweetness.” Eisenberg soon started receiving scripts from male Gen X auteurs who were making films that glanced backward. In 2005, he played Noah Baumbach’s acerbic teen-age avatar in “The Squid and the Whale,” about a high schooler who acts out when his parents divorce. In 2009, he played a younger version of the director Greg Mottola in “Adventureland,” about a bright but stunted college graduate who spends a summer working at an amusement park. Inhabiting such twitchy and isolated characters made Eisenberg himself feel increasingly twitchy and isolated. When he starred opposite Emma Stone in Ruben Fleischer’s 2009 slasher comedy, “Zombieland,” he got the impression that his character had to be constantly “anxious and scared,” he said. “So I just turned into this crazed person trying to keep myself in a petrified state. I would puke in my bed in the middle of the night.”
After “The Social Network,” Eisenberg tried his hand at larger Hollywood roles. He played a pompous magician in the blockbuster 2013 heist film “Now You See Me.” “I love doing the magic series,” he said, of the ensuing franchise. (He’s since made two more.) “My character is so confident in them, so I can kind of escape myself a bit.” The film was a commercial hit, but critics found it slight. They were even less fond of Zack Snyder’s 2016 superhero flick, “Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice,” in which Eisenberg played the villain, Lex Luthor, as an obnoxious tech bro. His histrionic performance earned Eisenberg that year’s Razzie Award for Worst Supporting Actor. “The studios stopped calling after that,” he said.
Eisenberg does not consider himself to be “a part of the film industry,” he told me, pronouncing the word as if it were an infectious disease. “It is so hungry for new things,” he said. “Like, you go to these awards shows, and they are giving out awards for Best First Film and Best Newcomer. They don’t do that at hospitals, you know? They don’t celebrate a guy who did his Best First Surgery.” We were having breakfast in Los Angeles, at the Tower Bar, a sceney restaurant in the Sunset Tower Hotel, where he was staying. It was early June, and Eisenberg had flown in to compete on the celebrity edition of “Who Wants to Be a Millionaire.”
He often compares himself, unfavorably, with his wife, whom he refers to in rhapsodic terms. “She’s, like, a saint,” he said. “She’s just an exceptionally good person.” He describes her family as “Marxist activists”; her brother is the late leftist historian Howard Zinn’s publisher, and her mother built a domestic-violence shelter in Bloomington in the seventies and ran it until her death, in 2017. Eisenberg and Strout have volunteered at the shelter, Middle Way House, and he credits his time there with giving him perspective on “the things that actually matter.”
Eisenberg likes trivia games, and agreed to be on “Millionaire” after learning that his winnings would go to a charity of his choice. He’d asked Giamatti to be his partner, and the day before, at the Sony Pictures lot, he’d spent an hour pacing around a trailer, analyzing the competition. “You have more general knowledge than other actors,” he told Giamatti. “You read. I’ve never seen an actor with a book.”
“Yeah, but I read mysteries,” Giamatti said. “Though I was an English major.”
“I might say ‘hermeneutics’ when I’m answering,” Eisenberg said. “Even if it isn’t relevant.”
“See, I don’t even know what hermeneutics are,” Giamatti said.
“That’s the genius,” Eisenberg said. “No one does.”
The two made it to the final round, and decided to walk away with half a million dollars. Eisenberg gave his half to Middle Way House. He’d enjoyed himself, he said at breakfast, though he was reluctant to admit it. He told me that he’d once tried seeing a Freudian analyst who, after a few sessions, diagnosed him with a complex called arousal disgust. Eisenberg was quick to clarify that “this was not a sexual thing” but, rather, “this idea that I will like things and then immediately feel disgusted.” He added, “Like, how talking to you makes me feel good about myself, which of course means that in about an hour I am going to feel incredibly embarrassed by it.”
His life is full of such equivocations, moments when he feels he must atone for his privilege. Banner attends private school and also frequently volunteers alongside his parents. Last summer, after Eisenberg received an award at a Czech film festival, he and his family drove to Ukraine to work at a children’s art camp for a week, spending one night in a bomb shelter.
The apotheosis of Eisenberg’s urge to carbon-offset the advantages of fame came last December, when he gave one of his kidneys to a stranger. He got the idea a decade earlier, after listening to a podcast about “altruistic organ donation.” “It felt so clean to me,” he said. He sent off a saliva sample to a company that made donor matches, but he heard nothing back.
Later, a doctor he met explained that he didn’t have to wait—he could just walk over to the N.Y.U. hospital and offer up an organ. That fall, Eisenberg was starring in an Off Broadway one-man show that he’d written, so he scheduled his operation for the first available weekend after it closed. Initially, those around him didn’t understand his decision—“I thought, This is maybe putting generosity on steroids,” his father, Barry, told me—but his family came around. “By the end of his time in recovery, his sister and I had inquired about beginning the process, too,” his mother, Amy, said. Kieran Culkin told me that he plans to hold on to both his kidneys. “But, when you hear Jesse’s reasoning, you gotta admit, Oh, shit, he’s right,” he said. “He’s, like, ‘Put me under and cut me open and take an organ from me!’ He’s terrified of everything, but he’s not nervous about that. It’s weird.”
When Eisenberg began writing “The Debut,” he originally set it in an unnamed suburb that could have been anywhere, or at least anywhere with a middling community-theatre scene. “I wanted it to feel out of time,” he said. But, while scouting locations, he found himself gravitating toward central New Jersey. For Mona’s house, he chose a sprawling split-level in Morristown, with frosted-glass doors and a knobby stone fireplace. The kitchen, with its ivory melamine cabinets and honey-colored oak trim, looked much like the one in the home where he’d grown up, in nearby East Brunswick. It occurred to him that he was making a period piece.
“I just felt, instinctively, like it had to be set in 1990,” he told me. He put a blocky landline in the kitchen, where Mona learns that she’s gotten the part. With the help of the costume designer, Stacey Battat, he dressed his heroine like a preppy car-pool mom in sherbet-colored cardigans and Peter Pan-collared shirts.
Eisenberg once joked that the best parts he’s written are “either for myself or a sixty-year-old woman.” Mona Friedman is somehow both. “She’s me when I was seven years old,” he told me. “She’s not a fully fledged adult.” He continued, “And then she enters this other world, this theatre world, where everybody is suddenly nice to her, and she is both delighted and overwhelmed, which is exactly what happened to me.”
Eisenberg was born in 1983 in Manhattan and first lived in Bayside, Queens, the second child of parents whom he describes as “normal, self-actualized, nice people.” Barry and Amy met at Queens College. They’d each grown up Jewish in the outer boroughs, and had Ashkenazi grandparents who’d immigrated to the U.S. (from Poland and Moldova) before the Second World War. After the couple wed, Barry got a job as a hospital administrator, and Amy worked as an amateur-theatre director—“high-school musicals, kids’ plays, that kind of thing,” she told me. One day, when Eisenberg was a baby, Amy filled in for a friend who had a gig as a party clown; she ended up clowning as Bonabini Tetrazzini Fettuccine Alfredo for the next fifteen years, before earning a doctorate in medical humanities.
When Eisenberg was around three and his older sister, Kerri, was six, the family moved to East Brunswick. (Hallie, the youngest, was born six years later.) Eisenberg, who has lived in Manhattan since he was eighteen and predicts that he will likely die there, often wonders what his childhood might have been like if his parents had never moved the family out of the city. He would have been less bored, perhaps, and therefore less driven toward creative pursuits, but he also might have felt less alienated from his environment. “It’s really hard to pinpoint exactly what happened to me or why,” he said. “I had good parents who loved me.”
In New Jersey, Eisenberg began to display signs of acute anxiety. He was smaller than other children, and his classmates made fun of him for his size and for his curly hair. As he remembers it, he was kicked out of one kindergarten classroom for locking his mother in a closet when she tried to leave him at school. In first grade, he cried every day on the bus. He would get spontaneous nosebleeds, triggered by stress. “I used to bring two tissues into school,” he said. “One for crying, and one for bleeding. They were in separate pockets.”

“You’re thinking of a canary. I’m a parakeet, and I have no goddam idea what is going on.”
Cartoon by Avi Steinberg
Amy and Barry assumed that their son was simply going through a phase. “He was just this sweet, sensitive kid, and we figured he’d be O.K.,” Amy said. Now they see things differently. “I sometimes think if Jesse was born twenty years earlier or twenty years later, it might have been easier for him,” Barry told me. “Twenty years earlier, if people were depressed—and I’m not saying this is good, necessarily—they kept that in.” He continued, “If he was born a little bit later, society in general, and certainly us more particularly, probably would have been more aware of what his issues were.”
Amy noticed that Eisenberg’s unease came, she told me, “with this rare sense of empathy.” From a young age, he was aware that there was suffering in the world, and seemed to feel a duty to mitigate it. The Eisenberg family was not very religious, but Eisenberg attended Hebrew school until he was ten, when he gave his parents a multi-page handwritten letter asking to drop out before his bar mitzvah, explaining that organized religion was responsible for violence and discord throughout history.
It was not uncommon for Eisenberg to write a letter arguing his positions. (He still does. Earlier this year, he wrote to the Directors Guild of America, with a plea to remove his name from “The Debut” ’s opening credits, as he felt that it was “an actor’s movie.” “My director’s card distracts from that fact,” he added; the guild said no, citing union rules.) Eisenberg’s linguistic dexterity appeared early. In elementary school, he carried around a Dictaphone to record one-liners as he thought of them. “He would always be ten paces ahead of us, talking into it,” Hallie said. “He would just get so annoyed when he couldn’t get to the joke fast enough.”
Eisenberg’s parents signed him up to perform with a local children’s theatre, hoping that it might raise his confidence. He instantly felt comfortable there. “Everything that the kids at school thought was odd about me was, like, incredible to these people,” he said. “It was, like, ‘You have the best hair for this play.’” His first big performance was in “an insane show called ‘Annie & Oliver,’” he said. It was “forty-nine per cent ‘Annie’ and forty-nine per cent ‘Oliver!’” Eisenberg soon joined larger-scale community productions—“The Secret Garden,” “Merrily We Roll Along.” He was sometimes one of the only kids in the cast, but he didn’t mind—he enjoyed conversing with adults. (“They understood anxiety and depression,” he said.)
Eisenberg began to feel as though he were living a double life. He was thriving in the theatre community, but the start of middle school, he told me, “was hell.” He stopped sleeping and began to display repetitive behaviors. His parents took him to see a psychologist, who asked Eisenberg if he’d ever thought about harming himself. He hadn’t, but, Eisenberg said, “she planted this seed in me that was, like, O.K., if I try to kill myself, people will understand how severe I feel. So I started hiding knives under my bed, and screaming to my parents that I was going to jump out the window. I don’t think I ever wanted to actually do anything, but I was just living in this state of terror.”
His parents made the decision to admit him to a local psychiatric hospital. “Something broke in him,” Amy said. “And we were just trying to help him be safe.” Eisenberg stayed less than forty-eight hours—his parents took him out, against medical advice—but he still remembers his short stay as horrific. He told me that someone had drawn a swastika on his wall, and that he was restrained, more than once, in a padded room. “He wasn’t there long, but he experiences it as a lifetime of a nightmare,” Barry said.
A year later, he got his big break when an agent saw him audition for a regional production of “Peter Pan” and signed him. At twelve, Eisenberg made his Broadway début, as an understudy in the Tennessee Williams play “Summer and Smoke.” At sixteen, he moved to Hollywood to take a lead role in a Fox teen drama called “Get Real,” as the youngest of three maladjusted siblings in a middle-class California family.
He was happy to leave high school, he told me, but in L.A. (where his father had come along as a chaperon) his enthusiasm for the job began to wane. “It became this incredibly mawkish melodrama,” Eisenberg said. “By, like, Episode 4, my character was in a coma from spinal meningitis.” One day, he and his father noticed that several of the actors had commandeered parking spots right outside the soundstage, while the crew had to use a faraway lot. Barry remembers his son being appalled by the blatant unfairness.
Eisenberg’s knee-jerk sense of justice has led to a few on-set altercations. “I got into a fight with an actor because the actor was taking a nap and then yelled at the P.A. who was supposed to wake him up,” he told me. Another time, he said, “I was in a movie with one actress who didn’t know her lines and was screaming at everyone.” He continued, “It was such a shocking display of disrespect and irresponsibility. So I yelled at her in front of the crew, and they ended up firing her. I cannot stand that stuff.” He added, “And it’s, like, God, for what reason? You’re in the arts.”
Eisenberg headed back East, where he transferred to the Professional Performing Arts School, in Manhattan, for his senior year. “That was the greatest time of my life,” he said. “I was studying drama with other people who loved it.” Around the same time, he discovered the films of Woody Allen, who became his comedic idol. Before seeing “Annie Hall,” Eisenberg told me, he hadn’t realized that it was possible “to make a movie about the things I like, about the people I know, and with the sense of humor that feels most personal and bespoke.” His first attempt to write a movie, at seventeen, was “Woody,” a bio-pic about Allen’s high-school years. Later, as a young actor, Eisenberg was often compared to Allen, and, in the twenty-tens, he appeared in two of the director’s films. “Honestly, it was not great,” he told me, of those experiences. “I didn’t really have an interesting role in either of the movies.” At some point, I texted Eisenberg (he is a prolific texter) to ask about his views on the sexual-abuse allegations against Allen. At first, Eisenberg made a joke about how texting may not be the best medium for nuanced dialogue about a controversial subject—“I’m supposed to send you a text message about Woody Allen? Is it in the career-suicide section of the article?”—but then he added, “I’m an ambassador for a domestic violence shelter in Indiana and if people are really interested in what I have to say on the matter, I’d like to direct them to make a donation.”
In 2001, Eisenberg was admitted to N.Y.U. to study writing—his application essay was about TV actors taking the best parking spots—but, that summer, he was cast in “Roger Dodger.” Against his parents’ protests, he decided to defer college to pursue acting, an anxiety-provoking decision at the time. “When I think about it now, that’s what ambition feels like for me,” he said. “Where it’s, like, the stakes are life and death for something that is not actually life and death.”
Most weekdays, if he isn’t on a film set or in postproduction, Eisenberg wakes up early and bikes uptown to a branch of the New York Public Library, where he sits at a table in the library’s lounge and writes for eight hours straight. “I’ll call him and say, ‘I haven’t seen you in months. Can we get lunch?’” his sister Hallie told me. “And he’s, like, ‘Well, no, I’ll be at the library writing from nine to five, but I can see you after.’”
Eisenberg began this routine almost twenty years ago with the screenwriter Jim Beggarly, whom he met through a mutual acquaintance in 2007. They started swapping works in progress (Eisenberg had begun writing plays), and before long, Beggarly suggested that they conduct regular tandem writing sessions.
One brisk day in early September, Eisenberg invited me to observe them in action. “It’s going to be riveting,” he joked. At the library, he led me into a large, fluorescently lit room full of Formica tables. Beggarly, who is sixty-one, was already sitting at one, guarding the pair’s computers. I asked Eisenberg if strangers ever interrupted them. “People are mostly fine,” he said. “It’s because there’s no sexuality to my work. I think once the public is asked to want to sleep with a person onscreen, that person’s life is fundamentally different.”
In Eisenberg’s twenties, as his acting career began to take off, he decided to get serious about writing. He wanted to make the most of his newfound proximity to directors and producers. “I was that awful, obnoxious actor who was asking everyone to read my scripts,” he said. “I would have cut off my leg to get something made.” Then Eisenberg got a sobering piece of advice from the actor and writer Bob Odenkirk, whom he’d asked to read a script, a broad comedy. “He said, ‘You’re a sensitive, thinking person. Why the fuck are you doing this?’” Eisenberg told me. He stopped writing screenplays and focussed, instead, on other pursuits, such as co-founding a website with his cousin called oneupme.com. Every morning, Eisenberg would post a setup (e.g., “She’s like Windex”) with a punch line (“Never streaked”) and encourage users to come up with better ones (“Now you see her, now you don’t,” “She clears everything up”). For years, he judged the contests himself.
In 2007, Eisenberg travelled to Bosnia to star in “The Hunting Party,” a black comedy about a war reporter. Afterward, he visited a distant cousin, Maria Binder, a Polish Holocaust survivor who’d made it through the war by hiding out with a Christian family. Her harrowing story threw Eisenberg’s career angst into stark relief. “I was complaining to her about my life and how I couldn’t get any scripts made, and she was telling me about the Holocaust,” he said. “I was, like, Oh, this is such a fascinating dynamic.”
It struck him that the encounter might make for a good play. The result was “The Revisionist,” about a privileged American novelist named David, who, struggling to finish his second book, travels to Poland to stay with an aging relative (also named Maria). David is furious with himself for being unable to write and numbs his distress by smoking weed. Eventually, Maria reveals a long-held secret: after the war, having lost her entire family in the camps, she stole the identity of a childhood friend who’d perished. The play poses big moral questions—Who earns the right to feel despair? What makes a family?—but resists easy answers.
Next, Eisenberg wrote “Asuncion,” about a pair of white college kids who take in a Filipina roommate and must confront their prejudices. The show débuted Off Broadway, at the Cherry Lane Theatre, in 2011, and, two years later, “The Revisionist” played in the same space, with Eisenberg as David and Vanessa Redgrave in the role of Maria.
Before he writes any dialogue, Eisenberg often composes lengthy monologues for each character, most of which never make it into the final product. This helps him feel a kinship with them, even when they are repellent. In his third play, “The Spoils,” which opened Off Broadway in 2015 and on the West End in 2016, Eisenberg starred as a rich, insecure stoner who bullies his roommate and confesses to having scatological fantasies about another friend’s girlfriend. “Jesse wrote such an unlikable character for himself,” his co-star Erin Darke told me. “Like he was trying to figure out how to not be that way.” Ben Brantley, in a rave review for the Times, wrote, “Eisenberg loves rolling in the sties of self-contempt,” adding that his character is “a jerk, for sure, but he’s also well-drawn enough to remind us of the jerk within us all.”
At the library, Eisenberg said that Beggarly, who is the credited writer on five small-budget independent films, quickly became the reader that he keeps in his head as he writes. “Jim knows a lot more about movies than I do,” he said. “And it feels like a nice, safe place to talk about an industry that I feel great ambivalence about.”
Beggarly held his hand to his cheek, pretending to blush. “The thing is, the scripts I write are about looking outward at people,” he told me. “Jesse is very inward. If I had made ‘The Debut,’ it would have been so focussed on how bad the musical is. Whereas Jesse wrote it in a way that was, like, Let’s all take it seriously anyway. Which is actually funnier.”
A ruminator and an inveterate recycler of his own ideas, Eisenberg first wrote “A Real Pain”—the story of two American cousins who take a luxury Holocaust tour of Poland to connect with the suffering of their Jewish ancestors, only to spend the entire time contending with their own neuroses—as an adaptation of a short story he’d published about two friends travelling through Mongolia. After stumbling onto an ad for a high-end tour of Auschwitz, he reset the story in Poland, pulling in themes he’d explored in “The Revisionist.” He typically writes first passes in unaddressed e-mails; the bulk of his work exists in his Gmail drafts folder.

“You could easily mistake Jesse for this über-nebbish,” Paul Giamatti said. “But,” he added, “he knows exactly what he wants to do. He’s really thought about it.”
Eisenberg has published twenty-five Shouts & Murmurs pieces for this magazine. (“But I submitted double that,” he clarified.) In 2015, he released “Bream Gives Me Hiccups,” a collection of humorous stories. But he continued to be seen in L.A. primarily as an actor. “Nobody in the movie industry cares if you have a play on, or if you have stories in The New Yorker,” he said. “I realized, suddenly, that I had mistakenly bifurcated my career.”
One person in the industry who did pay attention was Emma Stone, a friend since “Zombieland.” “I knew that because Jesse is so precise in how he writes, he would be equally precise as a director,” Stone told me. In 2020, she launched the production company Fruit Tree with her husband and took on, as their first project, “When You Finish Saving the World,” a film script Eisenberg had written about a self-righteous mother who runs a women’s shelter. Julianne Moore agreed to star, and A24 came on as a distributor. Stone also signed on to produce “A Real Pain.” Still, even with her name behind it, getting that film made was not easy. A24 passed, as did several other studios. “A24 gave me an interesting note, which is that they don’t really do movies like this anymore, which were not dramatically swinging for the fences,” Eisenberg said. “Like, it wasn’t ‘Marty Supreme.’”
Once Culkin signed on, funding came in, but Eisenberg was left feeling insecure. One day, he was framing a shot at a small military airport south of Warsaw when he began to fret about the cinematography. “We were shooting on a steadicam, which is the fastest way to shoot something,” he said. “And I was, like, Oh, no, are we making something that looks like every other thing? Is this boring?”
“A Real Pain” is not boring, but it is quiet. Its score is made up of spare Chopin études and nocturnes; some scenes, like one set in the Majdanek concentration camp, are silent. The film’s strength lies in its filigreed performances, particularly from Culkin, to whom Eisenberg said he was “eternally grateful,” even if the two had sometimes clashed during production. Eisenberg likes to stay on schedule (all his films have finished on time and under budget); Culkin is looser in his approach. “He didn’t want to talk about the script, or stand on his marks, or even know what scene we were shooting,” Eisenberg said. But, he added, “my character had to be both charmed by this guy and also unnerved by him, so that dynamic comes through.” (Culkin told me, “Not to, you know, kiss his ass, but it was so brilliantly written that there was nothing for me to do. I had zero questions.”)
Eisenberg always has a crisis of faith while filming. This can make the postproduction process challenging, he said, but it also pushes him into writing the next thing. While still in Poland, convinced “A Real Pain” would flop, he began the script of “The Debut.” He called this self-flagellating productivity hack a “survival mechanism masquerading as misery.” (Eisenberg is currently working on his first television series, with A24 producing, about a conservative college student who, in the wake of 9/11, finds herself drawn to a liberal professor.)
“The Debut,” which was originally titled “No One Cares,” is Eisenberg’s warmest and kookiest film to date, and also his most cinematically ambitious. He asked the movie’s director of photography, Drew Daniels (who shot the 2024 Best Picture winner, “Anora”), to give it a slightly garish affect; the camera swings around rooms to mimic the way that Mona’s head is on a permanent swivel. Once she discovers acting, she sees everything as dramatic: steam rising from the pavement, the flickering of a neon sign. She is like Dorothy, moving from black-and-white to Technicolor, and the fact that she has walked not into Oz but merely into a crumbling theatre is a sharp visual gag.
One afternoon, Eisenberg joked to Beggarly about wanting to write an absurdist scene between Mona and the musical’s director, Jerry, in which Jerry concocts an impromptu acting exercise for her. Holding an envelope that he says contains a rent check, he tells Mona to get it from him by any means possible. Mona starts off by playing the victim—“I’ll be living under a bridge and I’ll eat rats!” she cries. Then she turns angry, her frustration building until her eyes bulge. Pushed to an operatic breaking point, she unleashes a fusillade. “Jerry, you motherfucking ass-shit fucker-face piss man!” she shrieks. “The motherfucking rent is MOTHERFUCKING DUE!”
Eisenberg wrote the scene the night he thought of it, in fifteen minutes. “I wrote it mostly to make Jim laugh,” he said. “I figured such a long monologue would never make it into the final film.” Beggarly advised Eisenberg not to cut a word.
Sometimes, after a writing day, the two men grab dinner at a local diner. The night that he finished “The Debut,” though, Eisenberg announced that he wanted to go out to Tatiana, a fancy restaurant at Lincoln Center. “I thought, O.K., he thinks that he’s done something really great,” Beggarly told me. Eisenberg winced. “That feeling lasted maybe two days,” he said.
The première of “The Debut” at the New York Film Festival, in early October, began with a cocktail party at Brasserie Boulud. Many of Eisenberg’s intimates were there—Emma Stone, Claire Danes, his sister Hallie—but he mostly stayed huddled in a corner of the room, wearing a black suit and a skinny black tie (“the one formal outfit I own,” he said). On the walk to Alice Tully Hall, he was still debating whether he had the stomach to sit through the film.
Outside the theatre, fans were pressed against a barricade, holding out posters for “The Social Network,” “The Squid and the Whale,” and “A Real Pain.” Eisenberg stopped to sign a few, then proceeded into the main atrium, where he posed for pictures with the cast. His wife looked on protectively as he joked with journalists on the press line. I asked her if she thought he was happy that the film was coming out. “I think happy is too easy of an emotion for a person like Jesse to feel,” she said.
Eisenberg did end up staying for the screening, and so he was there when the audience clapped wildly, mid-movie, after Mona’s big rant. (“There was so much pleasure in saying that language,” Moore told me.) The next day, I asked him about it. “I feel... nothing,” he said, with a laugh. “What are normal people supposed to feel in that situation?”
Giamatti thinks of “The Debut” as a theological allegory. “It reads like one of these lives of a medieval saint,” he said. “Someone who turns themself over to something and puts themself through hell, basically in service of this higher purpose.”
Did Eisenberg see Mona as some kind of martyr, too? “If I had to pathologize this film, which I don’t like to do,” he told me, “I would say that maybe, as I’ve become more successful in the arts, I have increasingly missed the thing that felt really pure and communal, and that’s what this woman is struggling with. At the end, she finally realizes what it means to be on a team, and she sublimates her own needs for the greater good of the show.”
A few days later, Eisenberg texted to ask if I would make sure that he didn’t sound too precious. “If you represent me as an adult in any capacity,” he wrote, “I’ll count it as a win.”♦