Bloomberg the Company & Its Products The Company & its ProductsBloomberg Terminal Demo RequestBloomberg Anywhere Remote Login Bloomberg Anywhere LoginBloomberg Customer Support Customer Support
Connecting decision makers to a dynamic network of information, people and ideas, Bloomberg quickly and accurately delivers business and financial information, news and insight around the world
Americas+1 212 318 2000
EMEA+44 20 7330 7500
Asia Pacific+65 6212 1000
Connecting decision makers to a dynamic network of information, people and ideas, Bloomberg quickly and accurately delivers business and financial information, news and insight around the world
Americas+1 212 318 2000
EMEA+44 20 7330 7500
Asia Pacific+65 6212 1000
More
US Edition
Video 2

How China’s Intelligence Operations Target Tech
Video Player is loading.
Mute
Current Time 0:00
Loaded: 3.48%
00:00
1x
Playback Rate
2x
1.75x
1.5x
1.25x
1x, selected
0.75x
0.5x
0.25x
captions off, selected
English
This is a modal window.
Ad 0:15
Nov 14th, 2026
How China’s Intelligence Operations Target Tech
Former CIA counterintelligence analyst Peter Mattis tells Bloomberg This Weekend how China’s Ministry of State Security can use business and personal relationships to gather intelligence and potentially influence decision-making in strategically important industries. Speaking with hosts David Gura and Christina Ruffini, Mattis explains why technology executives can become valuable targets even without access to classified information and how AI is expanding the capabilities of Chinese intelligence operations.
1. ### How China’s Intelligence Operations Target Tech Now Playing
2. ### Inside Jensen Huang’s Last Hours as Nvidia CEO Duration:10:40
3. ### “Bigger Than a Business Story”: Nvidia Shakeup Duration:10:40
4. ### Stifel CEO on Anthropic, Integrating AI and Fed Policy Duration:7:37
5. ### Ground Stop Fix Will 'Take Some Time,' Mullin Says Duration:8:55
6. ### Morgan Stanley Wealth Mgmt. Head on Vinyl Equity Deal Duration:5:50
7. ### Tanker Hits Cruise Ship in New Orleans, Triggering Rescue Duration:0:43
8. ### Dan Ives Cuts Nvidia Price Target, But Stays Bullish Post-Huang Duration:3:18
10. ### Lutnick Under Fire as Bessent Blames Commerce for Nvidia Crisis Duration:9:40
11. ### Senators Ask Trump Administration to Preserve Nvidia Documents Duration:6:06
12. ### Ackman on Huang's Exit, Anthropic IPO Roadshow Duration:1:42
13. ### Nvidia Can Weather Huang's Departure, Ross Gerber Says Duration:3:27
14. ### LaHood Says Antiquated FAA System Likely Failed Duration:8:16
15. ### People Have 'No Idea' How Much Nvidia Impacts Daily Life, Says Aaron Brown Duration:8:46
16. ### Dan Ives on Nvidia Without Jensen Huang, Microsoft Outage Duration:5:57
0:00
The ousting of NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang began with a scandalous affair with whom it alleged
0:04
to have been a Chinese spy.
0:06
This left many wondering who exactly is Alice Huang, what were her objectives, and what was
0:11
the true nature of her work. Joining us now is former CIA counterintel analyst Peter Mattis.
0:17
He is now the president of the Jameson Foundation and author of the book Chinese Communist
0:22
Espionage, which is why we thought it might be good to talk to you. I have...
0:27
When you look at this woman, there are so many different questions. I think what is
0:31
unclear at the moment is, was she an agent or was she an asset? Does it
0:37
matter, and what is the difference?
0:41
So thank you first. Thank you for having me this morning, David and Christina. I think
0:45
the first thing to remember is that you could have an MSS official. Right? That's a
0:49
case officer. That's someone who is an intelligence officer who's handling sources, handling spies, directing them
0:55
at targets, or trying to exploit information coming. She almost certainly was not that. And there's
1:02
something in the Chinese system that's a little more sort of vague than an asset. Right?
1:08
This... She wasn't inside an organization that wanted to be recruited, but she was doing a
1:12
lot of things in business where you could see that she probably is connected to the
1:16
Chinese political elite. She's clearly connected to the tech elite in The United States, where the
1:24
Ministry of State Security has what we call co op these. And these are people who
1:28
are just collaborators, cooperative. They can be tapped when necessary. And in some cases, there's kind
1:33
of a mutual back scratching of, you know, you you... We do a favor for you.
1:38
You do a favor for us. And it it kind of goes back and forth.
1:44
Of course, I know how the CIA operates, the difference between it and the the FBI.
1:47
I've watched enough British shows to know the difference between MI five and MI six.
1:52
How about this? Documentaries on IT and TV.
1:54
Uh-huh. Ex... Explain sort of how the Ministry of State Security operates. How should we think
1:58
of it kind of in complement with those other intelligence agencies around the world?
2:02
In some ways, we should kind of think of it as being like the the old
2:04
KGB of having a a robust domestic mission and the international mission. You know, they collect
2:10
intelligence the same the same way that we do, the same way that others do. Right?
2:14
They think of of intelligences as activating or catalytic knowledge. Right? Information that solves decision making
2:21
problems. These are quotes from from some textbooks. The difference though that they have is that
2:28
they put a lot of effort into what we would call covert action, something that we
2:32
consider exceptional or special that requires a presidential finding. In their case, it's something that they
2:37
consider to be sort of routine, ordinary, you know, just another day that ends in y,
2:42
so to speak. And this is not the first kind of tech case where we've seen
2:46
transfers, and you can kind of get a sense that that intelligence is floating in the
2:51
background. Right? Because it's also used as a way to facilitate sort of critical business or
2:56
strategic business that that has a benefit for the Chinese state.
3:00
Because the public private partnership works very differently in China, I would imagine the corporate espionage
3:07
side works a little differently as well. Is it possible you can be going about your
3:10
business as a a legitimate person working in industry and and get a tap on the
3:15
shoulder from the MSS and you are suddenly doing work for the Chinese government?
3:20
That's absolutely the case. The 2017 intelligence law requires you to cooperate when someone presents legitimate
3:26
credentials and says, you know, do this for us. But there are a couple of big
3:31
differences in the way that they think about economic espionage and how they and how they
3:35
function. You may remember the Minsk raid... The raid many years ago. You may remember the
3:41
Rio Tinto raid in Shanghai almost twenty years ago. That this is where the Ministry of
3:47
State Security's counterintelligence resources were deployed to protect the financial interests of the Chinese party state...
3:54
Of Chinese businesses that had a that had a party state stake in them. So you
3:58
have this protective side. The second thing that you have is that we tend to think
4:05
of intelligence as being the collection of classified information kind of popular. As I mentioned, it's
4:10
about supporting decisions. And if you think about where the Chinese Communist Party is, they look
4:14
at The United States and they see themselves as being an existential competition. They see science
4:19
and technology as being the crux of that competition. And in particular, they see artificial intelligence
4:25
as fundamental to what will happen. And we've already seen tremendous changes in scientific discovery, in
4:31
the ability to launch information operations, in military operations because of AI. So if you are...
4:39
If you if you have the party's worldview and you see this, you're also gonna be
4:42
targeting companies because they're of critical national importance. They'll have, you know, no conversation between a
4:48
tax executive and the president. It's probably classified. So it's probably just sort of unclassified but
4:54
incredibly useful. You guys would probably consider it to be reportable and and interesting. And, you
5:00
incredibly useful. You guys would probably consider it to be reportable and and interesting. And, you
5:00
know, they have an interest in in trying to facilitate access to the the things that
5:05
they need to to lead in the AI race.
5:07
Peter, I wanna get your perspective on Jensen Huang's awareness of this or his recognition that
5:15
he could be subject to something like this. And I think of the trips that I've
5:18
taken to China at various companies, the kind of information security I've had to do before
5:23
going off and swapping out a phone or taking a different computer. I'm primed to think
5:27
that I'm entering an environment where things are different and I could be approached in a
5:31
different way or or looked at in a different different way. Here he is, one of
5:35
the wealthiest men in the world, running perhaps the most important company of the moment, supplying
5:39
chips at the vanguard of this new technology to companies all over the world. What do
5:44
you make of what seems like real naivete here?
5:48
Look. I've given security awareness briefings to to many corporate executives, and one of the things
5:54
that's kind of astonishing is that a lot of people say, well, I don't have classified
5:57
information. Why would I be a target? Right? That's kind of the first thing. And I
6:01
don't think it's unique. Certainly not unique to Jensen Huang, and it's certainly not unique to
6:07
Americans. It's just... It's something that we're... We haven't... If you haven't lived in that world,
6:12
you haven't really thought about it. And so you think of you think of spying as
6:15
being this particularly glamorous thing or or that you can get after these high value, you
6:20
know, precision points of information. Sometimes you can, but that's not always how it works. The
6:26
second thing is that I think a lot of people think of security and personal protection.
6:32
And... Right? Personal protection is one thing, but that's not what this is. The third, I
6:36
think a lot of people just don't have the the recognition of questions that they should
6:42
be asking about individuals who are thinking about what might be used what might be used
6:48
against them. Right?
6:49
Give give us a few examples of that. Give us give us a few of those
6:51
tools. What what should executives who may be watching wonder about or or the questions that
6:55
they should be asking if they go to China?
6:57
Well, they should be... Well, they shouldn't... I mean, first, this doesn't necessarily happen in China.
7:02
Correct. This can happen in Singapore. It could happen in Hong Kong. It could happen in
7:06
Kuala Lumpur. It could happen in Brussels or Paris. Right? It doesn't matter where where it
7:11
is. I think the first is, you know, know what know what your red lines are.
7:15
What are the things that that can't be talked about? Second, know what your value is,
7:19
particularly from a political side. Right? In one sense, you could see that there's very clearly
7:23
a benefit to the Chinese state in this operation in getting access to the chips, but
7:27
there's also access to political intelligence, conceivably the the ability to influence US policy. Right? These
7:34
things all exist together, and people should be cognizant of who is in their political circle,
7:40
who are they... Who's in their social circle. Right? What is it that I should be
7:44
talking about? I think a good rule, though, is if you're traveling abroad as an American,
7:48
don't talk about other Americans if you can possibly help them because you don't necessarily know
7:52
who you're dealing with, and you don't know who they're reporting to.
7:55
There's this meme that's been going around. Yes. I'm going there. And it's how to tell
8:00
if your girlfriend is a Chinese spy. And it's a joke, and it's tongue in cheek.
8:04
And it's, are you in tech? Yes. Is she more attractive than you? Yes. Spy. It's
8:08
it's ridiculous. But there has to be some sort of briefings, opsec. I have... I've heard
8:15
of people in high intelligence jobs being warned about this exact thing, being warned about young
8:21
attractive women approaching them for information. I've seen it happen. I've been with an intelligence officer
8:26
at a conference when a young woman went up and tried to get that person's information,
8:30
and that intelligence officer knew immediately what it was and shut it down.
8:34
You can say it on the new part.
8:36
I'm not... I am not saying that on television. How are these big CEOs not questioning
8:42
these relationships more, and is it up to people at these companies who could be watching
8:46
this happen to question some of these relationships?
8:51
All is gonna come down to personal awareness and personal choices. Right? And, unfortunately, you know,
8:58
the... There's a standard phrase for for the kind of levers of espionage called MICE. You
9:04
know, money, ideology, coercion, and ego. And, unfortunately, it works because these kinds of things play
9:12
on egos. People like to talk with smart people. People like to talk with others that
9:17
are kind of, you know, closely related to work, but maybe not quite, know, one
9:23
person an unnatural interest in cloud computing? Maybe we should question this.
9:28
Right. Right. Those those are the kinds of things that you should be asking. Like, are
9:32
the questions out of order? Are they are they detailed? Are they exactly business questions? Are
9:37
they political questions? And, you know, first and foremost, where do you... If you don't think
9:42
about this yourself about where do you draw your lines about what is important, what are
9:47
you going to do, then when you're in the moment, that's when you're going to be
9:50
the most vulnerable. So I think mostly, it's it's about preparing your your mentality, preparing your
9:55
thoughts, and saying, okay. Here's how I handle it. And by the way, here are the
9:59
reasons why it might be a target. I don't think a lot of people who are
10:00
reasons why it might be a target. I don't think a lot of people who are
10:02
outside of government, outside of holding a security clearance, really think of themselves as being as
10:07
being valuable.
10:08
Interesting.
10:09
But, obviously, they obviously, they are, and it's not for... Always for the for the reasons
10:14
that they think they would be.
10:16
Peter, we have about a minute left. I I am very curious as we talk about
10:18
somebody who was involved in AI, about the role that AI is playing in this kind
10:22
of spy craft. How is it changing the game for an organization like the MSS?
10:28
The Ministry of State Security is also one of the, I think, the only strategic civilian
10:33
signals intelligence services worldwide. They're mostly a military organ... Mostly military organizations like the NSA. And
10:39
the MSS is incredibly active with computer network exploitation. So AI, facilitates tool development. It facilitates
10:46
processing. They... It's been reported now for years that they have pretty robust relationships with the
10:52
cloud computing companies in in China and that they leverage those commercial resources to support them.
10:59
It allows them to process, you know, those huge reams of data that we've seen, like
11:03
the hack on United, Anthem Health, on Marriott, on the office of personnel management, and to
11:09
be able to combine all of these things and then use that technical knowledge and the
11:13
insights and leads gained to tip-off human operations. Yeah. Right? The the MSS focuses a lot
11:19
on the human element. Right? Hence, the emphasis on political action, on political influence, on facilitating,
11:26
you know, through human relationships, transfer of technology.
11:29
Okay.
11:29
So, you know, it supercharges what they can do and sharpens sharpens their teams.
11:34
Alright. Peter Mattis, thank you so much. Thank you for your insight. I promise to run
11:38
all future relationship approaches through you so you can make sure that they're on the up
11:42
and up. We appreciate your time.

Duration:10:40 ### Inside Jensen Huang’s Last Hours as Nvidia CEO

Duration:45:07 ### The Rise and Reckoning of Jensen Huang
Duration:10:40 ### “Bigger Than a Business Story”: Nvidia Shakeup
Duration:7:37 ### Stifel CEO on Anthropic, Integrating AI and Fed Policy
Duration:10:00 ### Bolivian Woman Takes on Lake Crisis in Green Doc Winner
Duration:8:55 ### Ground Stop Fix Will 'Take Some Time,' Mullin Says
Duration:4:53 ### Jensen Huang on AI Optimism and Nvidia’s Next CEO
Duration:3:42 ### Jensen Huang on Who Could Succeed Him as Nvidia CEO
Duration:5:50 ### Morgan Stanley Wealth Mgmt. Head on Vinyl Equity Deal
Duration:0:43 ### Tanker Hits Cruise Ship in New Orleans, Triggering Rescue
Listen on Apple TVListen on RokuListen on Samsung TVListen on Fire TVListen on Android TVListen on Rakuten TVListen on Haystack News
By accepting, you agree to our updated Terms of Service, including the arbitration provision and class action waiver. You understand that we process your information as described in the Privacy Policy, which may include sharing information about your use of Bloomberg.com with third parties. Accepting does not affect your right to opt-out at any time via the Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information link in the website footer.
Accept