Maki Yazawa uses her professional culinary experience to rigorously test the tools and techniques that help make cooking easier and more fun.
In August, my fiancé and I blew $231.89 on bottled water. This was money that could’ve gone toward our nascent honeymoon fund or my 401(k), or, at the very least, it could have covered a chicken-nugget-and-caviar dinner for two. We adopted our costly bottled-water habit about four months ago, so that’s nearly $1,000 down the drain. Gag. I’d been thinking about switching to a water filter for a while, but the bottled-water sticker shock was the last straw.
Look, we’re picky about drinking water. I can’t stand the taste of our Weehawken, New Jersey, tap water, and my fiancé frets about possible exposure to PFAS and trace lead. (To be clear, we’ve never actually found evidence of these contaminants in our water. And we should have taken my colleague Tim Heffernan’s advice about testing water quality before we stockpiled bottles.)
We’re renters, and we have a retractable kitchen faucet. So gravity pitchers, like the ones from Brita, are the only water filters we can use. But our Brita pitcher was gathering dust. Percolating filters can take forever, and you have to wait until the last drop hits the chamber below before you can finally pour a glass, which is why I’d abandoned the Brita for bottles. (In Tim’s words, every water-filtration system “has practical drawbacks, even those we recommend.”)
Then I heard that Ninja (a brand best known for its portable air fryers and slushie makers) had launched its first water filter, one that claims to solve many of the pain points of standard pitcher filters and meets water-filtration standards to boot. I was intrigued, if a bit skeptical: Brita pitchers work, and they cost less than $40, whereas Ninja’s machine costs about $250.
This countertop water-filtration system is certified to remove up to 99% of 80-plus contaminants. It dispenses water quickly and features refreshingly low-tech filter-life tracking.
These replacement filters have an estimated lifespan of six months or 120 gallons, whichever comes first.
Ninja’s HydraSense Countertop Water Filter is about the same size as a compact Nespresso coffee maker, and it’s similarly sleek. It doesn’t require a plumbing hookup, but it does need a power outlet to filter water, which it supposedly delivers “on demand.”
Ninja claims the system filters up to 99% of more than 80 contaminants, including microplastics, PFAS, heavy metals, and pharmaceuticals. But depending on the contaminant, actual effectiveness levels vary. Unlike many water filters, however, this one won’t strip minerals that make water taste good, such as magnesium and sodium.
The HydraSense’s filter meets multiple NSF/ANSI standards (which we require of all our filter recommendations), including those for taste, heavy metals and industrial chemicals, microplastics, and pharmaceuticals. In other words, it covers all of the “core” necessities, along with newer certifications for emerging contaminants, Siddhartha Roy, an assistant professor at Rutgers University whose research focuses on water quality, said in a video interview.
To determine if Ninja’s countertop filter could offer a meaningful step up from bottled water and pitcher filters, or if it was just another trendy gadget, I spent a month using it as my sole source of drinking water. And I even used it to filter water to boil pasta.
The trickiest part of the setup was finding a spot on our countertop where the machine would be near an outlet. After that, it took less than 10 minutes to get the HydraSense up and running; this included the quick, automated rinse cycle, which preps the activated carbon filter for use.
With the first few pours, I noticed that the water had a slightly plastic flavor, but it quickly disappeared. And since then the machine has reliably delivered balanced-tasting water that rivals high-quality bottled spring water in flavor. This is partly because it filters out chlorine, which is often added during the municipal water-treatment process to kill harmful microbes. That pool-like note “is definitely the main factor” behind off-tasting tap water, water sommelier Martin Riese said in a video interview.
All of our water-filtration picks, including a basic Brita Standard Everyday Pitcher, can greatly reduce chlorine, resulting in better-tasting water. And once chlorine is out of the picture, flavor-enhancing minerals (mainly magnesium, calcium, and sodium, according to Riese) can balance out the taste.
As it filters, the HydraSense filtration system preserves minerals, but it doesn’t add any. So the taste and mouthfeel are likely related to my municipal water’s overall composition, which gives the water its well-balanced profile. In other words, your mileage may vary.
I only wish the HydraSense could also chill water, even though I drink room-temperature water most of the time. If you prefer your water cold, you’ll need to add ice directly into the reservoir and recirculate the water, as Ninja recommends. Or you’ll have to detach the reservoir and pop it into the fridge until it’s ready to use (or decant it into a pitcher).
The HydraSense impressed me the most with its truly on-demand filtration speed; it’s a massive upgrade from the agonizingly slow trickle of pitcher filters. The HydraSense filtered 32 ounces of water (4 cups) in a mere 33 seconds, whereas it took my Brita Standard Everyday Pitcher 2 minutes 30 seconds.
As the name implies, a gravity pitcher uses gravity to slowly pull water through a filter into a lower reservoir — a process that can take up to 15 minutes. The HydraSense works with a powerful pressurized system that forces water through an ultra-fine, multi-layer filter. The pump lets out a guttural hum that crescendos as it pressurizes; the rumble is noticeably louder than the spa-like dribble of a Brita, but it’s over so quickly that I didn’t find it particularly obtrusive.
Since I started testing the HydraSense, my TikTok feed became flooded with videos of people using it to turn wine into water and to clarify pickle brine, in an apparent testament to the filter’s power. But unless you want to trash a filter and waste a perfectly good bottle of wine or jar of brine for clout, Ninja recommends sticking to plain tap water only — no carbonated drinks, untreated well water, or experimental liquids.
I found the HydraSense so efficient that I used it for everything I could, including boiling pasta and topping off my pets’ water bowls. With the machine’s removable drip tray, it was easy to fit taller water bottles and pots below; the nearly 10-inch clearance between the spout and the counter was never an issue. My fiancé and I were going through so much filtered water that we were constantly playing a game of chicken over who had to refill the tank next.
That brings me to an inevitable drawback of any freestanding filtration system, even one as efficient as the HydraSense: Its water delivery will never be as immediate as that of an under-sink or faucet-mounted water filter. Still, refilling it wasn’t a huge chore: I simply popped off the tank, filled it up at the sink, and snapped it back into place. And just like that, it dispensed 96 ounces of water as quickly as a soda machine — zero downtime required.
One of the grossest parts of using gravity pitchers is they can harbor whole ecosystems if you don’t clean them properly. While algae and mold growth is technically possible in a machine like the HydraSense, I didn’t notice anything while I was testing it. I kept the machine away from direct sunlight, which can encourage microbial growth, and I followed Ninja’s simple maintenance instructions. These include rinsing the reservoir once a week, running some components through the dishwasher once a month, and thoroughly cleaning the whole thing every time you replace the filter.
You don’t have to download yet another app, connect to Wi-Fi, or mess with AI to use this thing. And that can feel like a true blessing with a machine these days. There’s just a simple screen with a few helpful settings for manually dispensing and customizing pour sizes, including a “slow pour” mode, so you don’t splash water everywhere while filling ice trays.
The screen keeps track of the filter life and how much water you’ve filtered, and it notifies you when it’s time for a replacement. Tracking replacement timing was one of the things I hated the most about using a Brita — the impending doom of an expired-filter warning.
Unfortunately, the tracking isn’t totally glitch-free. At one point while I was testing, I noticed that the math seemed off: When the screen showed the filter life at 59%, the next screen claimed I had zero days left before needing a replacement.
I reached out to Ninja engineering manager Nathan Bollen, who confirmed that the “days left” mismatch is a known bug that the company is fixing on future units. “Installing a new filter would resolve the display issue, but it has the potential to occur again in power-cycling,” Bollen said in an email. (Since the filters are $40 a pop, you don’t want to replace them willy-nilly. So if this happens to you, pay attention to the percentage showing filter life, which should still be accurate.)
The HydraSense reported that we’d drunk roughly a gallon a day over about a month and that we’d filtered about 47 gallons in total and spared 359 (16.9-ounce) plastic bottles. It’s a wee bit concerning that our high daily usage has already put us on track to burn through the 120-gallon filter in roughly three to four months, rather than in the advertised six months.
At around $40 for one or $70 for a two-pack, the replacement filters aren’t cheap (Ninja offers discounts if you subscribe to automatic shipments). I ran the numbers based on my household’s estimated usage, and the HydraSense is more economical than relying on bottled water. But it’s much less cost-effective than other renter-friendly water-filter systems we recommend.
Still, for my specific household, the HydraSense’s unmatched convenience makes it worth the price. No other water-filter system on the market offers such lightning-fast filtration without a plumbing hookup. And that’s not to mention the effortless usage tracking.
But not everyone has my requirements or my impatience. And you may not need to filter your water in the first place. Unless you’re set on filtering water for flavor, we recommend that you test your water quality or look up a consumer confidence report (CCR) for your municipality before you commit. And if you decide you do want a filter, you have a few options.
Reverse osmosis systems can be pricey, both upfront and to maintain them. But they are your best bet if you want maximum filtration. Yet most reverse osmosis systems require under-sink plumbing work, produce wastewater, and require pricey remineralization cartridges to improve flavor.
Under-sink water filters come in a wide range of prices, and they provide endless filtered water on demand without taking up counter space. But you’ll still have to mess with your plumbing.
Gravity pitchers and dispensers are great low-cost, portable options for renters or emergency power outages. But they filter at a crawl and hold comparatively little water.
Faucet-mounted filters are a step up from standard pitchers, and they deliver filtered water on demand for a similar price. But they aren’t compatible with every faucet style, and they can be bulky.
Yes, all of our picks can get rid of contaminants and the icky chlorine flavor I despise. But Ninja’s debut water filter fills a largely overlooked niche in the filtration market by pairing unmatched countertop convenience with a neat, displayable package.
By bridging the gap between slow, low-capacity gravity pitchers and more-permanent solutions, the Ninja filter might herald a new era for home water filtration. And it could hit the sweet spot for renters, water guzzlers, or anyone seeking nearly instant clean water without hassle. Cheers to that!
This article was edited by Katie Okamoto and Annemarie Conte.
I cover all things kitchen-related, from how to correctly dispose of used cooking oil to how to decide whether the latest trendy cooking gadget is worth your time, money, and counter space. My goal is to share the best tools and techniques to help new cooks build confidence in the kitchen and to help seasoned cooks refine their skills.
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT